My 2002
Picks
Main Page
If I Picked the Winners...
WINNER
BEST PICTURE
'spellbound'
'mystic river'
'the return of the king'
Quentin Tarantino's latest is
a marvelous blend of
genres, styles, and film
stocks -- as witty as "Pulp
Fiction" yet as thrilling as
"Reservoir Dogs."  We can
only hope that the second
volume maintains the
adrenaline.
WINNER
BEST DIRECTOR
gus van sant,
'elephant'
peter weir,
'master & commander'
quentin tarantino,
'kill bill, vol. 1'
One can infer much about Sofia
Coppola the artist from her very
personal sophomore effort.  
She's always in complete
control of the medium, uniting
the talents of a strong technical
team to complement her themes
and evocative words.
WINNER
BEST ACTOR
johnny depp,
'pirates of the caribbean'
paul giamatti,
'american splendor'
jude law,
'cold mountain'
Penn's love for his
dead daughter is pitted
brilliantly against his
desire for vengeance
in this stern and fierce
portrayal -- a
performance that'll be
discussed for years.
WINNER
BEST ACTRESS
uma thurman,
'kill bill, vol. 1'
naomi watts,
'21 grams'
gwyneth paltrow,
'sylvia'
cate blanchett,
'the missing'
Comparing Uma to Charlize is the
epitome of apples and oranges,
and both women gave intense
physical and emotional
performances.  Perhaps where
Thurman beats the competition is
her perfect handle of the pic's
tongue-in-cheek humor.
Dread and despair never looked
so heartbreakingly real than
channeled through Gwyneth
Paltrow in this overlooked
biopic.  Why more critics didn't
rally behind her is a mystery;
she's equal parts haunting and
luminous.  But mostly haunting.
As usual, Blanchett looked
like an Oscar frontrunner
at the beginning of the
year only to wind up with
zilch by December.  No
worries -- she still turned
in a great trilingual and
multi-faceted performance.
WINNER
BEST
SUPPORTING
ACTOR
tim robbins,
'mystic river'
eugene levy,
'a mighty wind'
paul bettany,
'master & commander'
benicio del toro,
'21 grams'
With a flawless Bawston
accent, Robbins turned out
the best acting performance
of his career as a man
conflicted with guilt,
remorse, and shame.  He
also managed sympathy in
the film's darkest role.
Though Levy's characterization
is hyper-stylized, there's no
denying the inherent humor and
latent pathos in his aging folk
star.  Singing "Kiss at the End
of the Rainbow" with Catherine
O'Hara is the apex of the
bittersweet portrayal.
Benicio Del Toro proves that
being overly religious can be
scary stuff.  Or at least it is
for Jack Jordan -- a
character so racked with
conflicting questions of faith
and regret that
self-destruction makes sense.
WINNER
BEST
SUPPORTING
ACTRESS
ludivine sagnier,
'swimming pool'
scarlett johansson,
'lost in translation'
keisha castle-hughes,
'whale rider'
melissa leo,
'21 grams'
WINNER
BEST
ORIGINAL
SCREENPLAY
'pieces of
april'
'kill bill,
vol. 1'
'school of
rock'
'the station
agent'
The cinematography
may be coarse, but the
writing isn't.  In a series
of short, incisive scenes
that engage the viewer
like one-act plays, Peter
Hedges covers hilarious
emotional ground.
Tom McCarthy puts three
oddball characters together --
an introspective dwarf, a
grief-stricken housewife, and
a locquacious hot dog vendor
-- in scenes that could fulfill
every indie film cliche.  
Instead, it's a minor triumph.
WINNER
BEST
ADAPTED
SCREENPLAY
'mystic
river'
'american
splendor'
'girl with a
pearl earring'
'shattered
glass'
Some may claim that the
"Mystic River" script
skirts some issues and
lacks necessary
characterization.  I
found it to be rich in
conflict and full of
arresting dialogue.
You know it's a great
screenplay when it's difficult
to describe.  How else to
explain breaking down the
fourth wall and incorporating
animated and documentary
elements into an already
dense narrative?  Skillful.
Though the movie itself often plays like a
silent film, there's no denying the
dedication and energy that went into
making the novella a very watchable film.
 Words, obviously, aren't always needed
to convey important plot points, and the
characterizations in "Pearl Earring"
remain visibly astute.
Billy Ray makes journalistic
intrigue look as exciting as a
World War II film or Pixar
cartoon.  That's no small
feat, and luckily his acting
ensemble heightens his
words to classy heights in
this can't-miss drama.


For whatever reason, there's been a slow decline in the number of great movies
since 1999.  Each year when I come up with a list of my favorite performances, it
seems that the wealth is spread among fewer and fewer films.  There were still a
few keepers this year, though, so with that in mind, here are my picks for 2003:
'lost in translation'
peter jackson,
'the return of the king'
bill murray,
'lost in translation'
charlize theron,
'monster'
peter sarsgaard,
'shattered glass'
patricia clarkson,
'pieces of april'
The mystery of "Swimming
Pool" is mired in the mind of
an uptight novelist.  As the
object of affection (or at least
affliction), Sagnier one-ups
the always-commanding
Charlotte Rampling with her
lusty power-plays.
'lost in
translation'
'master &
commander'
Email me
Who my nominees and winners are in every major race.
'kill bill, vol. 1'
The best comedy (and
suspense film) of the year
features a group of kids
trying to spell their way to
the top.  Crafted with
meticulous care and a
great sense of story, it's
almost too funny for
words.
Clint Eastwood returned to
master form in 2003 with this
searing drama about the
interconnectedness of
childhood and adulthood --
and, by proxy, innocence and
guilt.  It took one of the year's
best acting ensembles to pull it
off.
After three years and three films,
Peter Jackson ended his monumental
work on the "Lord of the Rings"
trilogy with the most action-filled and
emotionally charged installment.  In
the end the ring was eventually
returned to Mount Doom -- and
perhaps made cinema history in the
process.
Sofia Coppola has created a mood
piece of supreme depth and emotion
with just her second film.  In this
travelogue of loneliness in Japan, she
also coaxed a career-best performance
out of Bill Murray and a star-making
turn by Scarlett Johansson.  And it all
lingers with you long after it's over.
sofia coppola,
'lost in translation'
Though "Gerry" was
an undernourished
experiment,
"Elephant" was a stark
observation of teen
angst in the most
vibrant manner
possible.
Peter Weir takes the timeworn
seafaring genre and makes one of the
most unconventional and rewarding
action films of the year.  The lack of a
standard story structure -- not to
mention an envigorating trip to the
Galapagos Islands -- is evidence of the
director's uniquely authentic stamp.
Tarantino's decision to mix in a
bloody good anime sequence
with already thrilling sequences
of swords, chains, knives, and
Uma Thurman's big toe is proof
that there are few working
American directors who can
perform at his manic level.
The scope of the project Jackson
undertook is almost unthinkable.  With
three classic novels that must have felt
like unwieldy beasts to adapt, the
director and his team have made what is
perhaps the greatest cinema trilogy of all
time.  Will "Godfather III" or "Matrix
Revolutions" be remembered this way?
Follwing her schizophrenic
performance in "Mulholland
Drive," Naomi Watts made a
complete about-face as a
drug-addled widow coping with
death and a volatile Sean Penn.  
Her grief is as electric as it is
harrowing.
The tricks of makeup should not
be forgotten.  But what Theron
achieves in her unflinching portait
or serial killer Aileen Wuornos is a
radical transformation of the soul.
 The gesticulations, the vocal
inflections, and the performance
are all Wuornos.  Charlize who?
sean penn,
'mystic river'
It may be part Pepe Le Pew and part
Keith Richards, but Depp's oddball
turn as a lecherously fey swashbuckler
is completely his own.  He's finally
getting recognition as one of the best
actors of his generation, but most of
us knew that already from his pair of
Edwards -- Wood and Scissorhands.
It's tough to make a firm
impression when you're playing
a real-life character who's
sometimes in the same frame.  
But Giamatti pulled it off grandly
as cartoonist Harvey Pekar in
this loopy docu-biography that
bristles with invention.
In a mostly reactive role, Jude
Law stands out during his
Homeric odyssey back to the
titular homestead with a mix
of realistic empathy,
determination, and strong will.
 His performance endures the
plot's sometime clumsiness.
Bill Murray wears two hats in his
sublime performance.  He's first and
foremost a funnyman -- witness his
cool wit when faced with the
non-English speaking photography
team.  But when Murray reveals the
joys and doubts of parenthood, it's
the serious side that leaves a mark.
This performance is stronger than
Russell Crowe's, mainly because
Bettany gets to act and react with
equal measure.  He's completely
believable as the ship doctor with his
sights set more on anthropology than
on cannons and mortar, and evokes
the period with determined realism.
He goes one-on-one with pathological
liar/journalist Stephen Glass (Hayden
Christiansen) and never bucks under
the pressure.  In fact, he even makes
the audience feel uneasy when calling
on the writer to justify the house of
cards he claims is truth -- an "All the
President's Men" for Generation X.
From one scene to the next,
Tarantino continues to
amaze with lightning-quick
humor and deft
characterizations.  It isn't as
talky as his prior works, but
"Bill" still exhibits the same
breath of fresh cinematic air.
Mike White -- who also took a small part
in the film -- blends grade school
innocence with high school music
sensiblities and post-college blues.  
Mixed together, he comes up with a
family film that speaks to the adult in
every kid and the kid in every
music-lover.  It's a class act all the way.
Much of "Translation" seems
improvised, but it's a tightly-scripted
rumination on indescribable love and
friendship that comes alive through
Coppola's words.  The characters feel
full-blooded, and none of the action is
forced.  Quite a start for her first
original screenplay.
"Lost in Translation" wouldn't be
half as good as it is were it not for
the touching performance by
Johansson as a young newlywed
already fearing she's made the
wrong choices in life.  She's
defiant, radiant, sensual...and you
can never take your eyes off her.
Decent child actors are so rare to
come upon.  Good ones.  Belivable
ones.  Ones that inbue their
performances with adult realism
instead of getting force-fed lines with
a flat delivery.  Keisha Castle-Hughes
is such an actress; hopefully this tiny
film is just the start.
She only makes a few
brief performances,
but each one is
shocking in its
intensity and in her
brave devotion to a
husband that's far
from perfect.
What isn't she great in?  She was
perfectly tormented in "The Station
Agent," perfectly hostile in "The Safety
of Objects," and perfectly clownish in
"All the Real Girls."  Yet she really
breaks your heart when looking at
pictures of her nude body pre- and
post-breat cancer in "April."  Brilliant,
Blending together the Patrick O'Brien
novels "Master & Commander" and
"The Far Side of the World," Peter Weir
and his team have fashioned an Old
Hollywood epic that doesn't play lip
service to its stars, special effects, or
fight scenes.  The interplay between the
crew is especially wonderful.
My 2001
Picks